When it comes to bathroom renovations, many homeowners reconsider installing a traditional garden tub. While garden tubs offer a spacious, luxurious soaking experience, they can consume significant space and may not align with modern bathroom designs or lifestyle needs. If you’re asking, “What to put in place of a garden tub?”—you’re not alone. This guide explores the best alternatives to garden tubs that combine style, function, and comfort without compromising your bathroom’s space and aesthetic.
In this article, we’ll dive into practical and stylish replacements for garden tubs, weighing the pros and cons of each option. Whether you want to save space, increase shower functionality, or create a spa-like retreat, these alternatives will help you make informed decisions tailored to your needs.
Why Consider Alternatives to a Garden Tub?
Garden tubs, typically larger and deeper than standard bathtubs, were once a symbol of luxury. However, they come with some challenges:
- Space Consumption: Garden tubs require ample floor space, limiting layout options.
- Maintenance: Larger surface areas mean more cleaning.
- Water Usage: Filling a garden tub uses more water, impacting utility bills and sustainability.
- Changing Preferences: Many homeowners now prefer walk-in showers or multifunctional spaces over oversized tubs.
Given these factors, exploring alternatives can help optimize your bathroom’s design and functionality.
Top Alternatives to Garden Tubs
1. Walk-In Shower with Bench
Why it’s a great replacement:
Walk-in showers are increasingly popular due to their modern look and accessibility. Adding a built-in bench provides a seating option akin to the comfort a garden tub offers.
Key benefits:
– Saves space and opens up the bathroom layout.
– Easier to clean and maintain.
– Improves accessibility for elderly or disabled users.
– Can incorporate luxury features like rainfall showerheads or steam options.
Pro tip: Use frameless glass doors to enhance the open, airy feel.
2. Freestanding Soaking Tub
If you still want a soaking experience but lack space for a garden tub, a freestanding soaking tub is an excellent alternative.
Benefits include:
– Sleek, stylish design that serves as a focal point.
– Smaller footprint than garden tubs, fitting in tighter spaces.
– Available in various shapes and materials (acrylic, stone, cast iron).
– Provides deep soaking without overwhelming the room.
Consider: Positioning near a window or with accent lighting for a spa-like ambiance.
3. Alcove or Drop-In Bathtub
For a more traditional yet space-efficient option, alcove or drop-in tubs fit snugly into corners or recessed areas.
Advantages:
– Maximizes bathroom space by fitting into existing layouts.
– Often less expensive and easier to install than garden tubs.
– Can be combined with a shower to serve dual purposes.
– Variety of sizes and styles to match your bathroom’s décor.
4. Wet Room Design
A wet room removes barriers between shower and rest of the bathroom, creating a fully waterproofed space.
Why consider a wet room?
– Eliminates the need for bulky tubs altogether.
– Ideal for small or minimalist bathrooms.
– Highly accessible and easy to clean.
– Allows creative use of materials like large tiles and waterproof paint.
Expert insight: Wet rooms are becoming a favored solution in contemporary home design due to their openness and versatility.
5. Jacuzzi or Whirlpool Tub Insert
If relaxation is your priority but space is constrained, consider a smaller Jacuzzi or whirlpool tub insert.
Benefits:
– Offers hydrotherapy benefits similar to garden tubs.
– More compact, fitting into smaller alcoves or niches.
– Adds value and luxury to the bathroom without major space demands.
Factors to Consider When Choosing a Garden Tub Alternative
When deciding what to put in place of a garden tub, keep these considerations in mind:
- Space Availability: Measure your bathroom carefully to determine what fits comfortably.
- Usage Needs: Do you prioritize soaking, quick showers, or accessibility?
- Budget: Some alternatives cost less to install and maintain than garden tubs.
- Aesthetic Preferences: Choose options that complement your design style—modern, classic, or rustic.
- Maintenance: Consider ease of cleaning and upkeep over time.
- Resale Value: Some bathroom features appeal more to future buyers.
Real-World Examples: Garden Tub Alternatives in Action
Case Study 1: From Garden Tub to Walk-In Shower
A family in Seattle replaced their bulky garden tub with a walk-in shower featuring a bench and dual showerheads. This change increased bathroom accessibility and reduced water consumption by 30%. The frameless glass door and large-format tiles enhanced the modern aesthetic.
Case Study 2: Small Bathroom with Freestanding Tub
In a New York City apartment, a freestanding soaking tub replaced a garden tub. The smaller tub fit perfectly in the compact space, maintaining a luxurious vibe while opening room for additional storage cabinets.
FAQs About Garden Tub Alternatives
Q: Can I remove a garden tub without major plumbing work?
A: It depends on your bathroom’s layout. Some replacements like drop-in tubs or shower conversions may require re-routing plumbing, so consult a professional plumber.
Q: Are walk-in showers more expensive than garden tubs?
A: Costs vary widely based on materials and features. Walk-in showers can be less expensive but adding custom features may increase price.
Q: How much water does a garden tub use compared to alternatives?
A: Garden tubs typically hold 60-90 gallons; standard showers use about 2 gallons per minute, making them more water-efficient.
Conclusion
Replacing a garden tub opens up exciting possibilities for your bathroom’s form and function. Whether you choose a sleek walk-in shower, a cozy freestanding tub, or a minimalist wet room, the right alternative can maximize space, enhance comfort, and elevate your home’s style.
Before making a decision, consider your lifestyle, bathroom size, and budget carefully. Consulting with a bathroom design expert can also provide personalized insights tailored to your space.
Ready to revamp your bathroom? Explore these alternatives to garden tubs and create the perfect sanctuary that fits your needs today.
Take Action: Start by measuring your bathroom and prioritizing your must-have features. Then, explore local showrooms or online galleries for inspiration. With thoughtful planning, your garden tub replacement can transform your bathroom into a modern, functional oasis.
